Revisiting David Hume’s Review of  the Rev. Robert Henry’s History of Great Britain:  Illuminating Hume on Religion, Politics, and Modernity

Mark G. Spencer

WEKO3

lat lon distance

[[sub_check.contents]]

[[sub_radio.contents]]

Field does not validate

[[sub_attr.contents]]　

インデックスツリー

アイテム

Revisiting David Hume’s Review of the Rev. Robert Henry’s History of Great Britain: Illuminating Hume on Religion, Politics, and Modernity

https://doi.org/10.34577/0002000126

名前 / ファイル	ライセンス	アクション
Revisiting David Hume’s Review of the Rev. Robert Henry’s History of Great Britain: Illuminating Hume on Religion, Politics, and Modernity (747 KB)

Item type

紀要論文 / Departmental Bulletin Paper(1)

公開日

2024-04-08

タイトル

Revisiting David Hume’s Review of the Rev. Robert Henry’s History of Great Britain: Illuminating Hume on Religion, Politics, and Modernity

言語

資源タイプ

資源タイプ識別子

http://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_6501

資源タイプ

departmental bulletin paper

ID登録

10.34577/0002000126

ID登録タイプ

JaLC

アクセス権

open access

アクセス権URI

http://purl.org/coar/access_right/c_abf2

著者

Mark G. Spencer

抄録

内容記述タイプ

Abstract

内容記述

It has been more than eighty years since E.C. Mossner first brought to the attention of modern scholars the pre-publication proof sheets of David Hume’s review of Volume Two of　the Rev. Robert Henry’s The History of Great Britain, from the Invasion of it by the Romans under Julius Caesar. Written on a New Plan (1774). Intended for the Edinburgh Magazine and Review, Hume’s review was supressed by the journal’s editors. Why? Mossner speculated Hume’s　critique was more favourable than the editors wanted. His account of Hume’s supposedly “kindly intended review” has been influential, being quietly absorbed as the unchallenged record. It’s time to revisit Hume’s review and to read it more closely than Mossner and those who have followed him did. Hume always expected diligent readers; in his review of Henry he provides them with an elaborate assessment. Unpacking Hume’s intricacies, we find him ironically playful and less praising than has been thought. When Hume’s review of Henry is
read closely—in the contexts of Henry’s History as a whole, Hume’s own History of England, and Hume’s telling final revisions to his History—we see he was quite critical of the core of Henry’s antiquarian account of England’s ancient times. And, all of this helps to illuminate Hume as the philosophical historian of the History of England, especially when it comes to the intertangled topics of religion, politics, and modernity. The essay concludes by fleshing out additional context offered by another anonymous Humean review, one which the author submits might usefully be seen as a companion piece to Hume’s review of Henry.

言語

書誌情報

ja : 人文科学研究：キリスト教と文化
en : Humanities : Christianity and Culture

号 55, p. 1-32, 発行日 2023-12-15

出版者

国際基督教大学(ja)

言語

ISSN

収録物識別子タイプ

ISSN

収録物識別子

24346861

戻る

views

See details

	Views

Versions

Ver.1

2024-04-08 01:21:23.295430

Show All versions

Cite as

エクスポート

OAI-PMH

JPCOAR 2.0
JPCOAR 1.0
DublinCore
DDI

Other Formats

JSON
BIBTEX

インデックスリンク

インデックスツリー

アイテム

Revisiting David Hume’s Review of the Rev. Robert Henry’s History of Great Britain: Illuminating Hume on Religion, Politics, and Modernity

× Mark G. Spencer

Versions

Share

Cite as

エクスポート